Skip to main content

Throwback | July 2014 | Opinion on Women Reservation Bill

Even the presence of three women in the three top posts of the Parliament-Speaker Meira Kumar, UPA Chairperson Sonia Gandhi and Leader of the Opposition Sushma Swaraj could not help in the passage of the Women Reservation Bill on the 21st of February last. Feminists believe it to be an unfair deal. They had been fighting for it since 1996! The 18 year old journey had seen high drama, frayed tempers, war of words as it hit many roadblocks. They believed it would be the epitome of Women Empowerment.

If we look back, we shall see that this bill was initially rejected by women representatives in the Constituent Assembly. They felt it was unnecessary since the working of democracy in its normal course would surely ensure the representation of all sections of the Indian Society.

I am against reservation per se and I have my reasons.

Reservation can never be the best way to achieve the goal of empowerment. It just ends up being divisive, deepening the chasm between the different sections of the society. Caste reservation and quota system has failed us so far, except on a few occasions, despite being in place for so long. Problems can never be solved by creating quotas. In fact I believe it to be an insult to us, Indian women, as this bill makes us only look inferior to men!

We can proudly say that we are equal to men, rather better in certain areas! I have never been a victim of gender discrimination. If I am qualified and worthy of a Job or a better Designation, I have always been given that. Why choose our leaders on the basis of their gender? Is being a woman enough to represent women?  We also have to keep in mind moneypower and nepotism. Will this bill remedy that? Will the elected lady representative be any different from the existing legislators?

Women will surely make better parliamentarians.They maintain dignity and do not climb up the dais or hurl non parliamentary abuses at the drop of a hat! But such reservations will only ignite groups with sparse representation in Parliment to start asking for quotas as well. Our constitution does not prohibit any law abiding eligible citizen from contesting in the polls. We do not need quotas in party tickets as well.

I wonder sometimes, if the bill is passed, and if duty even at the Siachen Glacier was made mandatory, would we allow our daughters to go for it? Are they made that way? One famous feminist had stated that if women have to face the freezing cold and the shelling there as well, men would become redundant. Well. That could be a way of putting it. But then, if we don't stand shoulder to shoulder, wouldn't this entire 'equality' business be a sham?

Having said that, even I might be tempted to actually support it since a little bit extra, a little boost is always welcome! But on a more serious note, it will infact be a step backwards and can safely be labelled 'superflous'. We are equal to men, aren't we?

(this piece was published in a city based tabloid in Guwahati)
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Guwahati's own 'Sonagachi'? Are we prepared?

Found this in my files today...something i had written sometime back...in a hurry... I will not defend them and say that they are victims. Despite the fact that most of them are here facing compulsion...they were lured by the money, the money which they need to provide a decent home to their impoverished families. They are now the living proof to the ever booming business of commercial sex in the gateway to the Northeast. Its not like we never knew about what goes on in some pockets of the city. Places like Pandu, Kalapahar, Paltanbazar, Rajgarh, Ganeshguri, Nabin Nagar or Beltola come alive every night. Its not like we never noticed the salwar kameez clad lady at the bus stop near the Judges Field, in the evenings. It has been just about a decade since she picked that vantage point! But we choose to feign ignorance. We want to believe that our brothers, uncles, boyfriend, husband or father would never notice them! Why do they stand at those particular spots then, night after nig...
1 comment
Read more

Complications 'acche hotey hain'!

Life hurls these weird complications at you sometimes, when feel trapped, between the devil and the deep blue sea. Thats when you need to take a leap of faith! And thats when you realise if those whom you have depended upon, catch you or just watch you drop into the abyss. And that is why sometimes, complications 'acche hotey hain'  That is one helluva silver lining, I tell you!
1 comment
Read more

Mother.....

Well I am a reporter in a news channel. We are often sent on specific assignments to cover certain events which sometimes turn out to be enlightening sometimes dissapointing and sometimes leave a deep impact on us. Well the only assignment which had my name against it today was 'Foundation stone unveiling ceremony' of the 'Vivanta', our very own Taj at Khanapara, Guwahati, by our CM, alongwith Ratan Tata and a host of other dignitaries. After having covered the event, I came back to office and sat in front of a machine with the sole intention of playing 'Farmville' on facebook. But that was not to be as I had hardly logged in that Parag Da, our Political Editor asked me to take a camera and rush to the Assam Enginering College where Ratan Tata was scheduled to attend another function. I admire Parag Da for his efficiency, wealth of knowledge and managing skills. He asked me to reach the Jalukbari Campus within 20 minutes...Ahem...20 minutes! He expe...
2 comments
Read more